| Docket information | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Case Number: | 18-978 | ||
| Case Type: | Civil (Civil_othr) | ||
| Docket Date: | 09-27-2018 | ||
| Bond Collected: | Yes | ||
| Docket Fee: | Yes | ||
| Pauper: | No | ||
| Case Closed: | Yes | ||
| Case Closed Date: | 12-23-2019 | ||
| Mediation: | No | ||
| File Date: | 09-24-2018 | ||
| File Time: | 10:48 | ||
| Print Deposit: | No | ||
| State Appeals: | No | ||
| Case Caption: | ROY A. COOPER, III, individually and in his official capacity as GOVERNOR OF THE STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA, Plaintiff, v PHILIP E. BERGER, in his official capacity as PRESIDENT PRO TEMPORE OF THE NORTH CAROLINA SENATE; TIMOTHY K. MOORE, in his official capacity as SPEAKER OF THE NORTH CAROLINA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES; CHARLTON L. ALLEN, in his official capacity as CHAIR OF THE NORTH CAROLINA INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION; and YOLANDA K. STITH, in her official capacity as VICE-CHAIR OF THE NORTH CAROLINA INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION, Defendants. |
||
History
| History | |
|---|---|
| Venue Origin: | Wake (10) |
| Heard In: | Superior Court |
| To SC: | |
| From SC: | |
Lower Court Number(s)
| Lower court case numbers | |
|---|---|
| Location: | Wake (10) |
| Judge: | Henry W. Hight Jr. |
| Case #: | 17CVS6465 |
Tracking/Argue
| Argue Date: | 03-27-2019 # |
Opinion
| Opinion Date: | 12-03-2019 | ||
| Cert Date: | 12-23-2019 | ||
| Author: | Honorable Lucy N. Inman | ||
| Decision: | Affirmed | ||
| Opinion Notes: | |||
| Opinion Pages: | 36 | ||
| Opinion Cost: | 7.20 | ||
| Cite: | |||
| Slip Opinion: | |||
Documents
| Document | Date Recvd | Cert of Service | Rec/Brf Due | Resp Due | Resp Recvd | Mailed Out | Ruling | Ruling Date |
| (1) RECORD | 09-24-2018 | 09-21-2018 | 09-28-2018 | |||||
| (2) M-EXT-BR | 10-16-2018 | 10-16-2018 | Allowed | 10-17-2018 | ||||
| (3) M-GEN | 11-01-2018 | 11-01-2018 | Allowed | 11-05-2018 | ||||
| (4) APPELLANT BRIEF | 11-13-2018 | 11-27-2018 | ||||||
| (5) INFORM SHT | 11-13-2018 | |||||||
| (6) APPELLEE BRIEF | 12-17-2018 | 12-19-2018 | ||||||
| (7) M-EXT-BR | 12-27-2018 | 12-27-2018 | Allowed | 12-28-2018 | ||||
| (8) REPLY | 01-10-2019 | 01-11-2019 | ||||||
| (9) M-CONTIN | 03-12-2019 | 03-12-2019 | Allowed | 03-14-2019 | ||||
| (10) COURT ORDER | 09-10-2019 | Other | 09-10-2019 | |||||
| (11) M-DSSAPP | 09-27-2019 | 09-27-2019 | Allowed | 10-01-2019 | ||||
| (12) ADD-AUTH | 10-11-2019 | 10-11-2019 | ||||||
| (13) CERT SAT | 02-14-2020 |
1 - RECORD
Filed: 09-24-2018 @ 10:48:00
For: Appellant Cooper, Roy A. (III) (Governor), et al
By: Mr. Daniel F.E. Smith BROOKS PIERCE MCLENDON HUMPHREY & LEONARD, LLP
2 - M-EXT-BR (Allowed) - 10-17-2018
Filed: 10-16-2018 @ 15:42:23
For: Appellant Cooper, Roy A. (III) (Governor), et al
By: Mr. Daniel F.E. Smith BROOKS PIERCE MCLENDON HUMPHREY & LEONARD, LLP
The following order was entered:
The motion filed in this cause on the 16th of October 2018 and designated 'Plaintiff Governor Roy Cooper's Consent Motion for Extension of Time to File Appellant Brief' is allowed. Plaintiff Governor Roy Cooper's appellant brief shall be filed on or before 13 November 2018.
By order of the Court this the 17th of October 2018.
3 - MOTION UNOPPOSED MOTION TO EXCEED WORD LIMIT ON PRINCIPAL BRIEFS (Allowed) - 11-05-2018
Filed: 11-01-2018 @ 16:46:07
For: Appellant Cooper, Roy A. (III) (Governor), et al
By: Mr. Daniel F.E. Smith BROOKS, PIERCE, MCLENDON, HUMPHREY & LEONARD, LLP
The following order was entered:
The motion filed in this cause on the 1st of November 2018 and designated 'Unopposed Motion to Exceed Word Limit on Principal Briefs' is allowed. Plaintiff-Appellant may file a brief not exceeding 10,750 words (proportional type) in length. Defendant-Appellees may file a brief not exceeding 10,750 words (proportional type) in length.
By order of the Court this the 5th of November 2018.
4 - APPELLANT BRIEF
Filed: 11-13-2018 @ 15:00:44
For: Appellant Cooper, Roy A. (III) (Governor), et al
By: Mr. Daniel F.E. Smith BROOKS, PIERCE, MCLENDON, HUMPHREY & LEONARD, LLP
5 - AIS INFORM SHT
Filed: 11-13-2018 @ 16:58:58
For: Appellant Cooper, Roy A. (III) (Governor), et al
By: Mr. Daniel F.E. Smith BROOKS, PIERCE, MCLENDON, HUMPHREY & LEONARD, LLP
6 - APPELLEE BRIEF
Filed: 12-17-2018 @ 17:22:39
For: Appellee Berger, Philip E. (Pres. Pro Tempore of NC Senate), et al
By: Mr. D. Martin Warf NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, LLP
7 - M-EXT-BR (Allowed) - 12-28-2018
Filed: 12-27-2018 @ 11:29:57
For: Appellant Cooper, Roy A. (III) (Governor), et al
By: Mr. Daniel F.E. Smith BROOKS, PIERCE, MCLENDON, HUMPHREY & LEONARD, L.L.P.
The following order was entered:
The motion filed in this cause on the 27th of December 2018 and designated 'Plaintiff-Appellant's Consent Motion for Extension of Time to File Reply Brief' is allowed. Plaintiff-Appellant's reply brief shall be filed on or before 10 January 2019.
By order of the Court this the 28th of December 2018.
8 - APPELLANT BRIEF REPLY
Filed: 01-10-2019 @ 14:09:59
For: Appellant Cooper, Roy A. (III) (Governor), et al
By: Mr. Daniel F.E. Smith BROOKS PIERCE MCLENDON HUMPHREY & LEONARD, LLP
9 - M-CONTIN (Allowed) - 03-14-2019
Filed: 03-12-2019 @ 09:29:42
For: Appellant Cooper, Roy A. (III) (Governor), et al
By: Mr. Daniel F.E. Smith BROOKS, PIERCE, MCLENDON, HUMPHREY & LEONARD, L.L.P.
The following order was entered:
The motion filed in this cause on the 12th of March 2019 and designated 'Joint Motion to Continue Oral Argument of 27 March 2019' is allowed. If necessary, this Court shall enter a subsequent order at the appropriate time notifying counsel when to appear for oral argument.
By order of the Court this the 14th of March 2019.
10 - CT_ORDER COURT ORDER (Other) - 09-10-2019
Filed: 09-10-2019 @ 14:55:59
For:
By: Hon. Linda M. McGee
The following Order was entered:
This case was calendared for oral argument on Wednesday, 27 March 2019, before a panel consisting of Judge Donna Stroud, Judge John M. Tyson and Judge Lucy N. Inman.
IT IS NOW ORDERED that this case shall be orally argued before the same panel on Tuesday, 15 October, at 9:30 a.m. Counsel are directed to appeal for oral argument in the North Carolina Court of Appeals Building, Raleigh, North Carolina.
11 - M-DSSAPP (Allowed) - 10-01-2019
Filed: 09-27-2019 @ 11:50:35
For: Appellant Cooper, Roy A. (III) (Governor), et al
By: Mr. Eric M. David BROOKS, PIERCE, MCLENDON, HUMPHREY & LEONARD, LLP
The following order was entered:
The motion filed in this cause on the 27th of September 2019 and designated 'Plaintiff-Appellant's Motion to Withdraw Appeal Relating to Volkswagen Trust Claims Only' is allowed.
By order of the Court this the 1st of October 2019.
12 - MEMOS ADD-AUTH
Filed: 10-11-2019 @ 17:06:54
For: Appellee Berger, Philip E. (Pres. Pro Tempore of NC Senate), et al
By: Mr. D. Martin Warf NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, LLP
13 - CERTIFICATE OF SATISFACTION
Filed: 02-14-2020 @ 14:12:20
For: Appellant Cooper, Roy A. (III) (Governor), et al
By: Mr. Eric M. David BROOKS PIERCE MCLENDON HUMPHREY & LEONARD, LLP
Financial Information
Receipts
| Date Charged | Charge Type | Amount | Amount Paid | Document | Pages | Receipt # | Date Paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01-10-2020 | Certification Fee | 10.00 | 10.00 | R012027320 | 01-21-2020 | ||
| 12-19-2018 | Printing | 330.75 | 330.75 | APPELLEE BRIEF | 189 | R122038518 | 12-31-2018 |
| 09-27-2018 | Docket Fee | 10.00 | 10.00 | R092038918 | 09-27-2018 | ||
| 09-27-2018 | Bond | 250.00 | 250.00 | R092038918 | 09-27-2018 | ||
| 09-28-2018 | Printing | 570.50 | 570.50 | RECORD | 326 | R102011518 | 10-12-2018 |
| 11-27-2018 | Printing | 103.25 | 103.25 | APPELLANT BRIEF | 59 | R122001018 | 12-03-2018 |
| 01-11-2019 | Printing | 42.00 | 42.00 | APPELLANT BRIEF | 24 | R012025219 | 01-23-2019 |
| 12-03-2019 | Assessment | 89.75 | 89.75 | R122017619 | 12-13-2019 |
Invoice : V122007819
Payments
| Payment Date | Payment Type | Amount | Check Number |
|---|---|---|---|
| 01-08-2020 | Disburse | 330.75 | 45039 |
Parties
| Party Name | Role |
|---|---|
| Cooper, Roy A. (III) (Governor) | Plaintiff-Appellant |
| State of North Carolina | Plaintiff-Appellant |
| Berger, Philip E. (Pres. Pro Tempore of NC Senate) | Defendant-Appellee |
| Moore, Timothy K. (Speaker) | Defendant-Appellee |
| Allen, Charlton L. (Chair of NC I.C.) | Defendant-Appellee |
| Stith, Yolanda K. (Vice-Chair of NC I.C.) | Defendant-Appellee |
Attorneys
Attorney for Appellant - Cooper, Roy A. (III) (Governor), et al
Mr. Jim W. Phillips, Jr. [Primary Attorney]
Attorney at Law
[email protected]
Mr. Eric M. David
Attorney at Law
[email protected]
Mr. Daniel F.E. Smith [Primary Attorney]
Attorney at Law
[email protected]
BROOKS PIERCE MCLENDON HUMPHREY & LEONARD, LLP
1700 Wells Fargo Capitol Center 150 Fayetteville Street Raleigh, NC 27601
(336) 271-3139
Attorney for Appellee - Berger, Philip E. (Pres. Pro Tempore of NC Senate), et al
Mr. Noah H. Huffstetler, III [Primary Attorney]
Attorney at Law
[email protected]
Mr. D. Martin Warf
Attorney at Law
[email protected]
NELSON MULLINS RILEY & SCARBOROUGH, LLP 4140 Parklake Ave., Suite 200 Raleigh, NC 27612
(919) 329-3881